In a shop recently, I was almost persuaded to buy some Mogami XLR cables. The sales guys said that there's an audible difference between using cheap XLRs and high-end ones, but we didn't have time to test their assertion. Is there any truth in this? I understand that they might last longer — but can they really sound better? My main use in this case would be for feeding active studio monitors.
Via SOS web site
SOS Technical Editor Hugh Robjohns replies: The short answer is no, they're very unlikely to sound any better. The longer answer is that there are complexities and subtleties involved that can, in specific circumstances, conspire to affect the sound when using different types of cables and connectors.
In essence, provided that the cable is appropriate in terms of its construction — particularly in having low capacitance and good screening — and the connectors used are of good quality and manufactured to meet the appropriate specifications, then there is no audible difference that I have ever detected reliably.
Are branded audio cables better than unbranded ones? Probably not, but they might be worth it anyway! The problem is that some inferior cables allow interference to get in via the cable or connectors, or have some inappropriate properties such as high capacitance, or they are wired in a way which creates ground-loop problems, and in those cases a properly made cable may appear to work better, simply because the reality is that the inferior cable didn't work properly. However, you should be aware that some very expensive cables are not built properly either (and, amazingly enough, that's often on purpose!)
Are branded audio cables better than unbranded ones? Probably not, but they might be worth it anyway! The problem is that some inferior cables allow interference to get in via the cable or connectors, or have some inappropriate properties such as high capacitance, or they are wired in a way which creates ground-loop problems, and in those cases a properly made cable may appear to work better, simply because the reality is that the inferior cable didn't work properly. However, you should be aware that some very expensive cables are not built properly either (and, amazingly enough, that's often on purpose!)
Mogami cables are generally well made and fit for purpose (so you should have perfectly decent cables there!) but so too are a great many other branded and unbranded cables. I tend to make all my own cables, but if I have to buy pre-made ones I always look for genuine Neutrik connectors — I reason that if someone is going to the trouble of fitting those, the chances are they know how to choose a decent cable too, and wire it up correctly!
Published June 2014
No comments:
Post a Comment